It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
So I drafted in the 10 spot and took Calvin Johnson and the guy took Rodgers at 9. Its a standard league scoring.
I would give up Calvin and Luck and would get Rodgers and B. Marshall. I know I should do it but I'm getting cold feet.
I would do it, its basically like trading your first and what 5th or 6th for luck for a 1st and 2nd pick.
Dont hesitate, take this before he realizes hes making a mistake
If you haven't processed this trade by now, something is wrong.
definitely go for it. youll get more combined points out of marshall and rodgers for sure
to put it in perspective in fantasy draft value, you're going to get a 1st and 2nd rounder in rodgers and marshall, and trade away a 1st and 4/5/6th in calvin and luck
trade locked in. Ty all
Nice deal for you.
wow what an awesome deal! you definitely made the right move.
I don't get it. If the other guy wanted Johnson he could have just taken him then if he wanted Luck he could have taken him a round early like in the 5th or 6th and been able to keep Marshall.
You won the trade but it isn't a disaster for the other guy. You gave up the best player in the deal. Yeah I realize Rodgers was selected ahead of Johnson but Johnson is the best player in the deal.
Using RJ's ranking on this site you gave up the #1 WR and #5 QB to get the #4 WR and the #2 QB.
The point difference between Calvin and Marshall, in non PPR is about 25 points (based on projections), and the point difference between Rodgers and Luck is about 70 points.
In PPR, I think it makes it about even.
You gained in this trade, around 50 points IMO.
You seriously upgraded your QB, and some may say its a downgrade from Megatron to Marshall, but that gap is much less than what you gained in your QB.
I like the trade.